The research aims to explore in an exhaustive way the interconnections between the discipline of geography and cartography in school teaching, with particular attention to the didactic and ideological implications that emerge from their interaction. Geography, as a hinge discipline, plays a crucial role not only in the education of students, but also in reflecting, and sometimes in mediating, on the political dynamics and the dominant thought of a society. The focus of the investigation focuses on a central question: to what extent do geography and cartography present themselves as impartial tools? Are they really such, or do they have implications with political thought or with historical events of capital importance? How have these disciplines evolved in the Italian educational context from the Second World War to the present day? The thesis is divided into three main chapters, each of which addresses a distinctive aspect of the evolution of geography in Italian education, with the aim of outlining a complex and multidimensional panorama. The methodology adopted is based on a comparative and critical analysis, which includes the examination of ministerial programs, of the main historical events and of their reflection in geography school textbooks. School textbooks have been selected as representative samples for each significant period, thus allowing us to grasp the nuances and transformations that have characterized the teaching of geography during the twentieth century and beyond. The first chapter offers a detailed overview of the succession of ministerial programs for elementary and middle schools. Through a chronological analysis, the transformations and continuities in geography teaching are highlighted, showing how educational policies have been influenced by historical, social and cultural contexts. The connections between political decisions and teaching choices are revealed. This chapter emphasizes how geography is not just a set of technical knowledge, but a field in which cultural identities and values are reflected and constructed; it can be used to shape the minds of the masses. The second chapter focuses on the analysis of the representation of Italy in school textbooks, examining the evolution of the patriotic imagery and the way in which it has been transmitted through geographical knowledge to young students. Through a critical analysis of the contents, illustrations and narratives proposed, it highlights how the geographical representations of the nation in school textbooks have been shaped by ideological currents and cultural changes, contributing to the construction of national identity. This chapter offers an insight into Italian cultural history, showing how school geography can influence students' perceptions of their country and the world around them, as well as their understanding of concepts such as identity, belonging and citizenship. The third chapter addresses a topic of great historical and geopolitical relevance: the eastern Italian border. Through an in-depth analysis of the events related to this territory, disputed between Italy and Yugoslavia during the twentieth century, we reflect on how school geography has treated these events and how cartographic representations have influenced students' perceptions regarding questions of identity and territoriality. This chapter aims to reveal some political and cultural complexities related to a border that has had a significant impact on Italian history, illustrating how geography teaching can contribute to the formation of a collective imagination and a critical understanding of geopolitical dynamics. In summary, this thesis offers a significant contribution to the understanding of the role of geography and cartography in Italian education, revealing the complex interactions between geographical knowledge, political ideologies and teaching practices. The research invites us to reflect on the need for greater critical awareness in the transmission of geographical knowledge and on the importance of an educational approach that fosters a pluralistic and inclusive vision in the education of new generations. In an era in which questions of identity, citizenship and belonging are increasingly central to public debate, it is essential that the teaching of geography is not limited to a mere transmission of data and information but is committed to developing in young students a deep and nuanced understanding of the complexities of the contemporary world. Only through an education that values diversity and promotes intercultural dialogue, can we prepare new generations to become aware and responsible citizens, capable of facing global challenges with an open mind and respect for differences. In this way, geography and cartography can truly assume the role of tools for building a more equitable and sustainable future.

Implicazioni degli strumenti geo-cartografici nei manuali scolastici del Novecento: spunti e riflessioni / Rogante, M.. - (2025 Mar 28).

Implicazioni degli strumenti geo-cartografici nei manuali scolastici del Novecento: spunti e riflessioni.

Rogante, M.
2025-03-28

Abstract

The research aims to explore in an exhaustive way the interconnections between the discipline of geography and cartography in school teaching, with particular attention to the didactic and ideological implications that emerge from their interaction. Geography, as a hinge discipline, plays a crucial role not only in the education of students, but also in reflecting, and sometimes in mediating, on the political dynamics and the dominant thought of a society. The focus of the investigation focuses on a central question: to what extent do geography and cartography present themselves as impartial tools? Are they really such, or do they have implications with political thought or with historical events of capital importance? How have these disciplines evolved in the Italian educational context from the Second World War to the present day? The thesis is divided into three main chapters, each of which addresses a distinctive aspect of the evolution of geography in Italian education, with the aim of outlining a complex and multidimensional panorama. The methodology adopted is based on a comparative and critical analysis, which includes the examination of ministerial programs, of the main historical events and of their reflection in geography school textbooks. School textbooks have been selected as representative samples for each significant period, thus allowing us to grasp the nuances and transformations that have characterized the teaching of geography during the twentieth century and beyond. The first chapter offers a detailed overview of the succession of ministerial programs for elementary and middle schools. Through a chronological analysis, the transformations and continuities in geography teaching are highlighted, showing how educational policies have been influenced by historical, social and cultural contexts. The connections between political decisions and teaching choices are revealed. This chapter emphasizes how geography is not just a set of technical knowledge, but a field in which cultural identities and values are reflected and constructed; it can be used to shape the minds of the masses. The second chapter focuses on the analysis of the representation of Italy in school textbooks, examining the evolution of the patriotic imagery and the way in which it has been transmitted through geographical knowledge to young students. Through a critical analysis of the contents, illustrations and narratives proposed, it highlights how the geographical representations of the nation in school textbooks have been shaped by ideological currents and cultural changes, contributing to the construction of national identity. This chapter offers an insight into Italian cultural history, showing how school geography can influence students' perceptions of their country and the world around them, as well as their understanding of concepts such as identity, belonging and citizenship. The third chapter addresses a topic of great historical and geopolitical relevance: the eastern Italian border. Through an in-depth analysis of the events related to this territory, disputed between Italy and Yugoslavia during the twentieth century, we reflect on how school geography has treated these events and how cartographic representations have influenced students' perceptions regarding questions of identity and territoriality. This chapter aims to reveal some political and cultural complexities related to a border that has had a significant impact on Italian history, illustrating how geography teaching can contribute to the formation of a collective imagination and a critical understanding of geopolitical dynamics. In summary, this thesis offers a significant contribution to the understanding of the role of geography and cartography in Italian education, revealing the complex interactions between geographical knowledge, political ideologies and teaching practices. The research invites us to reflect on the need for greater critical awareness in the transmission of geographical knowledge and on the importance of an educational approach that fosters a pluralistic and inclusive vision in the education of new generations. In an era in which questions of identity, citizenship and belonging are increasingly central to public debate, it is essential that the teaching of geography is not limited to a mere transmission of data and information but is committed to developing in young students a deep and nuanced understanding of the complexities of the contemporary world. Only through an education that values diversity and promotes intercultural dialogue, can we prepare new generations to become aware and responsible citizens, capable of facing global challenges with an open mind and respect for differences. In this way, geography and cartography can truly assume the role of tools for building a more equitable and sustainable future.
28-mar-2025
37
FORMAZIONE, PATRIMONIO CULTURALE E TERRITORI
La ricerca si propone di esplorare in modo esaustivo le interconnessioni tra la disciplina geografica e la cartografia nell'insegnamento scolastico, con particolare attenzione alle implicazioni didattiche e ideologiche che emergono dalla loro interazione. La geografia, in quanto disciplina cerniera, svolge un ruolo cruciale non solo nella formazione degli studenti, ma anche nel riflettere, e talvolta nel mediare, sulle dinamiche politiche e il pensiero dominante di una società. Il fulcro dell’indagine si concentra su una domanda centrale: in che misura la geografia e la cartografia si presentano come strumenti imparziali? Sono realmente tali, oppure presentano implicazioni con il pensiero politico o con eventi storici di capitale importanza? Queste discipline come si sono evolute nel contesto educativo italiano dal secondo dopoguerra fino ai giorni nostri? La tesi si articola in tre capitoli principali, ognuno dei quali affronta un aspetto distintivo dell'evoluzione della geografia nell'istruzione italiana, con l'intento di delineare un panorama complesso e multidimensionale. La metodologia adottata si basa su un’analisi comparativa e critica, che prevede l’esame dei programmi ministeriali, dei principali eventi storici e del loro riflesso nei manuali scolastici di geografia. I testi scolastici sono stati selezionati come campioni rappresentativi per ogni periodo significativo, permettendo così di cogliere le sfumature e le trasformazioni che hanno caratterizzato l'insegnamento della geografia nel corso del Novecento e oltre. Il primo capitolo offre una panoramica dettagliata della successione dei programmi ministeriali per le scuole elementari e medie. Attraverso un'analisi cronologica, si evidenziano le trasformazioni e le continuità nella didattica della geografia, mostrando come le politiche educative siano state influenzate da contesti storici, sociali e culturali. Vengono rivelanti gli intrecci tra decisioni politiche e scelte didattiche. Questo capitolo sottolinea come la geografia non sia solo un insieme di conoscenze tecniche, ma un campo in cui si riflettono e si costruiscono identità e valori culturali; di esso ci si può servire per plasmare le menti delle masse. Il secondo capitolo si concentra sull'analisi della rappresentazione dell'Italia nei manuali scolastici, esaminando l’evoluzione dell’immaginario patriottico e il modo in cui sia stato trasmesso attraverso le conoscenze geografiche ai giovani studenti. Per mezzo di un’analisi critica dei contenuti, delle illustrazioni e delle narrazioni proposte, si mette in luce come le rappresentazioni geografiche della nazione nella manualistica scolastica siano state modellate dalle correnti ideologiche e dai cambiamenti culturali, contribuendo alla costruzione dell'identità nazionale. Questo capitolo offre uno spaccato della storia culturale italiana, mostrando come la geografia scolastica possa influenzare le percezioni degli studenti riguardo al proprio paese e al mondo circostante, nonché la loro comprensione di concetti come identità, appartenenza e cittadinanza. Il terzo capitolo affronta un tema di grande rilevanza storica e geopolitica: il confine orientale italiano. Attraverso un'analisi approfondita delle vicende legate a questo territorio, conteso tra Italia e Jugoslavia nel corso del Novecento, si riflette su come la geografia scolastica abbia trattato questi eventi e come le rappresentazioni cartografiche abbiano influenzato la percezione degli studenti riguardo a questioni di identità e territorialità. Questo capitolo si propone infatti di svelare alcune complessità politiche e culturali legate a un confine che ha avuto un impatto significativo sulla storia italiana, illustrando come la didattica della geografia possa contribuire alla formazione di un immaginario collettivo e a una comprensione critica delle dinamiche geopolitiche. In sintesi, questa tesi offre un contributo significativo alla comprensione del ruolo della geografia e della cartografia nell'educazione italiana, rivelando le complesse interazioni tra sapere geografico, ideologie politiche e pratiche didattiche. La ricerca invita a riflettere sulla necessità di una maggiore consapevolezza critica nella trasmissione delle conoscenze geografiche e sull'importanza di un approccio educativo che favorisca una visione pluralistica e inclusiva nella formazione delle nuove generazioni. In un'epoca in cui le questioni di identità, cittadinanza e appartenenza sono sempre più centrali nel dibattito pubblico, è fondamentale che l'insegnamento della geografia non si limiti a una mera trasmissione di dati e informazioni, ma si impegni a sviluppare nei giovani studenti una comprensione profonda e sfumata delle complessità del mondo contemporaneo. Solo attraverso un'educazione che valorizzi le diversità e promuova il dialogo interculturale, possiamo preparare le nuove generazioni a diventare cittadini consapevoli e responsabili, capaci di affrontare le sfide globali con una mente aperta e un rispetto per le differenze. In questo modo, la geografia e la cartografia possono davvero assumere il ruolo di strumenti per la costruzione di un futuro più equo e sostenibile.
File in questo prodotto:
File Dimensione Formato  
ROGANTE_tesi.pdf

accesso aperto

Descrizione: Implicazioni degli strumenti geo-cartografici nei manuali scolastici del Novecento: spunti e riflessioni.
Tipologia: Tesi di dottorato
Licenza: Creative commons
Dimensione 7.91 MB
Formato Adobe PDF
7.91 MB Adobe PDF Visualizza/Apri

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11393/353055
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact